What is wrong with this exactly?

Can the mod who deleted this give me a reason?

Deletion reason was 'poor quality artwork'

May I get second opinion from another mod?

I've undeleted it to allow for comment. I've seen worse, but the proportions are all over the place. Look at those feet...

I've seen worse anatomy and proportions on images that were kept, and it has a nice line style.

To be honest, this artist is just bad. But this one is at least better than post #359178 and post #359291

Alright, thank you.

fireattack said:
To be honest, this artist is just bad. But this one is at least better than post #359178 and post #359291

What's wrong with post #359178 other then the strange arms? Though the hands are done so well I suspect they were traced.

post #359291 is pretty badly done, but I had to look twice to spot it.

Radioactive said:
What's wrong with post #359178 other then the strange arms? Though the hands are done so well I suspect they were traced.

Hard to tell, just feel that his/her way of coloring is pretty "cheap".. with all these weird textures

Unless there is a pressing need I'll nuke these images.

fireattack said:
To be honest, this artist is just bad. But this one is at least better than post #359178 and post #359291

You guys really need to learn to give better critique ...
Yes, there are flaws here and there but the overall thing looks well done.
In most of his/her works you can see that he/she puts a lot of effort into it and all you have to say is "this artist is just bad". Not even giving him/her your thoughts of what could use improvement, just like the other guy Radioactive says, you just wanna nuke this artist into nothingness instead of hoping that he/she improves - helping him/her improve.

Kosura said:
You guys really need to learn to give better critique ...
Yes, there are flaws here and there but the overall thing looks well done.
In most of his/her works you can see that he/she puts a lot of effort into it and all you have to say is "this artist is just bad". Not even giving him/her your thoughts of what could use improvement, just like the other guy Radioactive says, you just wanna nuke this artist into nothingness instead of hoping that he/she improves - helping him/her improve.

Honestly, I agree. I see much much worse art on here, such as the countless low-effort promotional/magazine art. This artist really isn't that bad in comparison and at least tries to put effort in their work. I think https://yande.re/post/show/359178 is quite distinctive and impressive with the lighting, even if it isn't really my 'style'.

Kosura said:
You guys really need to learn to give better critique ...

Yes, but I don't want to write a 500-word essay on why this artwork is not up to scratch. No-one would read it anyway.

here we go again. Person who uploaded this wanted to share it with the rest of us. The feet are, well not pretty, but I've seen a lot worse, the face is pretty dumpster as well. All in all it's not that bad, but you forget about it the second you've seen it. And a score of 47 speaks of itself. Personally, I'd rather delete Radio's avatar picture before this.

But getting to the point, I used to be a perfectionist. Is every tag right, does this picture really belong here? Or like when I was personally offended with Matsuyan's terrible photoshop attempt on a picture I liked. Meanwhile, last picture I've seen he's gotten a lot better.

But truth be told, it really doesn't matter if the tags are right or not, it also does not matter if the picture is deleted or not, as it's never fully gone. Just like in real life, we just have to ignore some things, be it people or mods.

So long.

Schezza said:
So long.

Close the door on your way out.

Radioactive, you decided to delete this image in the end in spite of what others have to say. I agree that this image is not exceptionally well done, however in my opinion, not outlandishly bad either.

Well, thanks for giving everyone a chance to take a look.

I respectfully accept your decision, as you are one of the moderators, who has been here the longest and know what's best for this site.

I didn't delete all this artists work, only the ones that objectively had issues.

Kosura said:
give better critique
giving him/her your thoughts of what could use improvement

Doesn't belong here. She/he can't see.