Close
Cyberbeing said:
Ultimately I still think a new rating should be added for images that fall between hardcore and non-nude/partial-nude 'ecchi' images.

You sound like you don't like the idea, and admin2 also sounds against, but he seems to classify the different ratings a bit closer to what I have been thinking.
I don't think there are any problems with the current rating system. What you suggest will just complicate matters. I'm with admin2, and petopeto on this.

When I rate images I use a similar system to vistigris, but you still have to use your common sense. I spend more time in trying to judge when a S image becomes Q. That isn't always am easy choice to make.