Not monster_girl.

Arsy said:
Not monster_girl.

It says: "Half-human, half-monster girls. Does not include girls with animal_ears."

It doesn't say it excludes girls with wings, horns and other non-human bodyparts.

But this 98% human, not Half.

Arsy said:
But this 98% human, not Half.

Almost all monster girls are mostly human with some minor accessories and rarely exactly half.

Here it was a mod who added the monster_girl tag: post #670297

dick_dickinson said:
Here it was a mod who added the monster_girl tag: post #670297

Do you forgot about Mermaid? mermaid monster_girl

Arsy said:
Do you forgot about Mermaid? mermaid monster_girl

The sketchy blob in the background? I didn't forget, I deliberately ignored.

This one only has a tail and a pair of horns, roughly 80% human? post #370299
This one has a full horse body, at least 90% horse. post #279912
100% human, but with 1 eye: post #331591
Eh... she has long tongue? post #311220
A small demon tail and horns. post #407828
Some fins? post #455596

As I said, the half-human, half-monster thing is very loose on the "half" part. I don't even know why is it not 'part-human, part-monster' instead.

dick_dickinson said:
As I said, the half-human, half-monster thing is very loose on the "half" part. I don't even know why is it not 'part-human, part-monster' instead.

Uh, if you pretty sure this monster_girls, then please add it hanekawa_hasumi.

Arsy said:
Uh, if you pretty sure this monster_girls, then please add it hanekawa_hasumi.

Yes, because characters absolutely has no variations. Or should I add animal_ears and tail tags to all nishikino_maki artwork as well, because there are some that has them?

IMHO, as long as they (still) have human hands and feet (instead of claws, or legs being replaced by tails, for example), they're still normal human.

Unless you want every angel or devil has this tag, too.

If we are talking about opinions and not rules, then IMHO kemonomimi is also a subgroup of monster girls and I've never seen a normal human or even an abnormal with wings. I've heard of horn and tail like disfigurements, but I hardly think those are normal. IMHO an argument could be made that devils/demons are monsters (sometimes with human characteristics).

This also introduces the question: Ar vampires (post #772946 post #772929) monsters, monster_girls or a category of their own? Because even if physically or in their origin they are/were human, conventionally vampires are considered monsters or demons, but they are excluded in the devil definition.

Moderation should be based on rules instead of opinions. Add angels and devilss to the exceptions in the definition of monster_girls and I concede.

dick_dickinson said:

Moderation should be based on rules instead of opinions. Add angels and devilss to the exceptions in the definition of monster_girls and I concede.

So since this one is an angel-like character, monster_girl shouldn't be added, then.

And ganyu_(genshin_impact)'s horns are classified as goat horns in Danbooru, so she's also not a monster girl.