Danbooru-based image board with a specialization in high-quality images.
aki

Edit | Respond

tag啊,不正确啊,应该是 chinese clothes
banana23 said:
tag啊,不正确啊,应该是 chinese clothes
That tag doesn't exist.
banana23 said:
tag啊,不正确啊,应该是 chinese clothes
Sorry, I was doubting about it... > <
If they're chinese I can only remove the japanese_clothes one.
i think there're enough images which should be tagged with chinese_clothes to make such a tag.
Lamphare said:
i think there're enough images which should be tagged with chinese_clothes to make such a tag.
agree
blooregardo said:
no need
but tag chinese dress exists
khankazz165 said:
but tag chinese dress exists
exactly, what for more chinese clothes?
blooregardo said:
exactly, what for more chinese clothes?
Because people complain when tagged as Japanese_clothes
看起來不是典型的漢服...
blooregardo said:
exactly, what for more chinese clothes?
china dress is not chinese clothes in narrow sense. and it's only one kind of chinese clothes in very broad sense -- it's just used much more often in anime/manga than any other style.

bakaneko said:
Because people complain when tagged as Japanese_clothes
there are some critical differences between chinese clothes and japanese clothes(though japanese clothes are diverted from older styles of chinese clothing). those are, furisode(swinging sleeves) are square, back-stretching collar and evidently wide girdle as in japanese clothes(styles). and some other minor ones.

for this perticular female dress, it seems more like a blend of both chinese and japanese clothing to me, but to be one nor another. however the male's cloth is definitely chinese.

hirotn said:
看起來不是典型的漢服...
女裝有點不像.更像和服和漢服的糅合= =
但是男裝的短打比較正.
blooregardo said:
exactly, what for more chinese clothes?
actually no this tag is not bad, as cate:chinese clothes is not so important. but if exist also not bad

Lamphare said:
女裝有點不像.更像和服和漢服的糅合= =
但是男裝的短打比較正.
this work alone seems much like japanese style. paper strips on sasa (small bamboo) obviously japanese tanabata there is. however that doesn't mean tag japanese clothes is appropriate. i also think the clothes on heroine intermingles japanese and chinese style
Lamphare said:
there are some critical differences between chinese clothes and japanese clothes(though japanese clothes are diverted from older styles of chinese clothing).
Thus I've suggested multiple times to rename "japanese_clothes" to a more generic "asian_clothes" or perhaps "traditional_clothes" to allow correct tagging.
khankazz165 said:
actually no this tag is not bad, as cate:chinese clothes is not so important. but if exist also not bad
what the hell do you mean chinese clothes aren't important?! chinese clothing is the origin of japanese clothing, idiot.

also, the female clothing to me looks like a mixture of both chinese and japanese clothing
the fact that there is both a top and an overal to the outfit and also the design makes it look chinese
the ribbon the clothing is held together by looks like one on a kimono and the sleeves look more triangular-like that of a kimono
the male's clothing is obviously chinese because of it's chinese style and patterns
StayCold said:
khankazz165 said:
actually no this tag is not bad, as cate:chinese clothes is not so important. but if exist also not bad
what the hell do you mean chinese clothes aren't important?! chinese clothing is the origin of japanese clothing, idiot.

also, the female clothing to me looks like a mixture of both chinese and japanese clothing
the fact that there is both a top and an overal to the outfit and also the design makes it look chinese
the ribbon the clothing is held together by looks like one on a kimono and the sleeves look more triangular-like that of a kimono
the male's clothing is obviously chinese because of it's chinese style and patterns
may I have your attention to what I posted. I'd wrote that is the cate:chinese clothes "is" not impartant cause there're not so many works relative to chinese clothes except chinadress. on the one hand I think I'd said specifically I agreed with making a tag such as this. and on the other hand the necessity is a consideration what is actual. I'd never said chinese clothes theirselves are not important
bakaneko said:
Thus I've suggested multiple times to rename "japanese_clothes" to a more generic "asian_clothes" or perhaps "traditional_clothes" to allow correct tagging.
i dont see the point renaming "japanese_clothes". it's already broad enough, making it into "asian_clothes" further garbles the various styles of somewhat different origins. and "traditional_clothes" makes even less sense. it virtually includes everything that's not modernly designed/originated.
personally i'm alright without "chinese_clothes" tag on site, as long as "japanese_clothes" is not arbitrarily or unconcernedly applied to clothings that are very clearly chinese, though i believe most of the time ppl tag with care.

however if the future trend does bring us an increasing number of pics with chinese clothing, i suppose making such tag with simple explaination(of how to differentiate whether one is chinese or japanese) would be grateful.
though most Japanese clothes get tagged under more specific tags - miko yukata kimono - this tag is more used for clothes that don't fit there, which is not a huge number - a quick check shows that there are more of the top 3 than of japanese_clothes on the site, and there's not much double-tagging. Also, something like chinadress shouldn't be double-tagged.
中国から伝わった風習で
七夕Tanabataといいます。
日本に定着した伝説です。
Discussing this in comments isn't going to get anything changed. Probably best for one of you to create a forum thread.
These two people are Chinese but the characters are reformed in Japanese and Korean stories. So its hard to say whether its chinese clothes or japanese clothes (lie on the artists) ^ ^ However traditional(before 1644) Chinese clothes and Japanese clothes do have a lot in common ,diffent with the tagged "chinadess" ,which appeared after the year 1644 of the Manchus conquest and laterly it was developed in 20th century. Maybe tag "Chinese_clothes" or "traditional_Chinese_clothes" will be fine. Sorry for discussing in comments. > <