Close
It doesn't look ugly, but I think it can be improved. It loses enough detail that the difference is visible even in the 1363x1000 sample image.

I'm playing around with it in greyc to see if I can do better, but I don't have any special talent here. If anyone wants to give a shot: try taking post #51908 and filtering it so the noise is minimized, but the fine details remain (watch the background pattern, the wood grain underneith, the small highlight on her eyes, and the highlights on the water drops). Don't crop the image, so any variants can be compared right on top of each other.

One attempt in post #51914: just a simple greyc pass (amp 80, sharpness .6, aniso .3, alpha 2, gfact 1.5) and then resized down to 2303x1689. More noise is visible, but it removes enough so it looks more like texture than an artifact, and more details are preserved.